Make your own free website on
  July 16, 2003 22:18:59

Section Front• Section Front

E-mail This StoryE-mail This Story  Printable VersionPrintable Version

Senate Dems Blame Bush, Not CIA

WASHINGTON, July 16, 2003

CIA director George Tenet leaves a closed Senate Intelligence hearing on Capitol Hill in Washington Wednesday, July 16, 2003.  (Photo: AP)

"This was not handled in a way that I would describe as being the most efficient, to say the least."
Sen. Pat Roberts, R-Kan.

Iraq: After Saddam
Saddam's Top Lieutenant Captured

Iraq's Most Dangerous City

Dan Rather/Saddam Hussein Interview

Postwar Iraq

The Hunt

Most-Wanted Cards

Daily Photo Diary

(CBS/AP) Senate Democrats insisted Wednesday that the White House was clearly responsible for including false information about Iraq's weapons program in President Bush's State of the Union speech.

Senators spoke after Tenet made a 4½-hour closed-door appearance before the Senate Intelligence Committee. Tenet repeated his statement that he bears responsibility for allowing Bush to include his State of the Union speech a claim that Iraq had sought uranium from Africa for a nuclear weapons program.

But Sen. Richard Durbin, D-Ill., said the issue wasn't why Tenet failed to keep the information out of the speech but who was so determined to put it in and why.

"All roads still lead back to 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue," he said, referring to the White House address. "The question is, Who in the White House was so determined to put information in the State of the Union which had been discounted so dramatically by American intelligence sources?"

Durbin and other Democrats said Tenet had named White House officials who had sought to include the information in the speech, but the Democrats declined to identify them, citing the confidentiality of the proceedings.

CBS Chief White House Correspondent John Roberts reports that as the political controversy continues to swirl, the FBI has launched a preliminary investigation into the sourcing of the intelligence on the Iraq. One of the issues the bureau is looking into is the possible motives someone would have for misleading the White House.

Responding to a question, committee Chairman Pat Roberts, R-Kan., said White House officials could possibly be called before the panel to discuss the handling of the intelligence.

He described Tenet as "very contrite. He was very candid, very forthcoming. He accepted full responsibility." Tenet did not speak to reporters, except to describe his appearance as an "uplifting experience" as he left.

Roberts said it was clear "there were mistakes made up and down the chain." He said the hearing reaffirmed his belief that "the handling of this was sloppy."

Roberts also said he expected to hold open hearings on the Iraq intelligence, probably in September.

Both the Senate and House intelligence committees are holding inquiries on whether prewar intelligence was inaccurate or mishandled to help Bush make the case for war. Democrats have stepped up demands for a formal investigation after the White House acknowledged that the uranium claim was false.

That claim, supported by British intelligence but discounted by U.S. officials, was apparently based on a series of forged documents suggesting that Saddam Hussein sought uranium from the African nation of Niger.

Bush and his national security adviser, Condoleezza Rice, blamed Tenet for failing to seek removal of the statement from the speech. Tenet issued a statement accepting responsibility.

But Sen. Ron Wyden, D-Ore., said "the CIA in my judgment was not pushing to have this matter of Niger included in the State of the Union speech."

"I believe that there was if not a battle royal between the CIA staff and the White House staff, certainly some back and forth," he said. "I believe that in this case, the White House political staff was looking at every rock, every nook and cranny to make their case and I believe the political staff prevailed," he said.

A senior law enforcement official said the FBI has opened an investigation into the documents. The focus is on who could benefit from putting false information into U.S. hands.

The official said the FBI is not investigating the U.S. government, but is looking at a variety of foreign entities, from other governments to anti-Saddam groups that favored a U.S. invasion.

The FBI sent a letter last week to Sen. Jay Rockefeller, D-W.Va., saying it had opened the inquiry. Rockefeller had called for such an investigation last spring. A spokeswoman for Rockefeller, Wendy Morigi, said the FBI investigation had actually begun a couple of months ago.

Sen. John Edwards, D-N.C., a presidential candidate and member of the Senate Intelligence Committee, said Bush should take responsibility for the reference to the Niger uranium.

"The responsibility is not the CIA's; it's not anyone else's. It is the president's responsibility. And those 16 words (about the uranium) were spoken by the president and he has to take responsibility for them," he said.

Tenet's appearance had been planned before he took responsibility for the uranium information being included in Bush's speech, Roberts said. He had been scheduled to discuss information sharing with U.N. inspectors.

Before the hearing, Roberts also denounced the "partisan flavor" of the discussion.

"I think that's to be expected when you have that many presidential candidates," he said.

In other developments:

  • A former chief U.N. weapons inspector says the search for WMD should concentrate on the capacity to make weapons in "war situations" rather than focus on old weapons and weapons systems. Rolf Ekeus says hoping to find barrels with chemical weapons is unrealistic, because that type of weapon cannot be stored.

  • British Foreign Secretary Jack Straw now says the case for war with Iraq was not based on "intelligence reports," the Times of London reports.

  • An Italian newspaper, La Republicca, has published documents it claims are the ones used as evidence of the Niger link. According to the Times of London, the papers are obvious forgeries: One is both addressed to and signed by Niger's president, another is dated in 1999 but refers to a treaty signed in 2000, and a third bears the name of a minister who'd left his post 11 years before the document was signed.

  • ©MMIII, CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.

    Back to Top Back To Top

    Help  • Advertise  • Feedback  • Terms of Service  • Privacy  • CBS News Bios
    ©MMIII, CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved.

    • On The Scene
    • War On Terror
    • World
    WMD Claim Debated
    See what key players are saying about the president's statement on Iraq's WMD program that's come under scrutiny.

    The Hunt
    Searching for Iraq's most-wanted people and weapons.

    Fallen Heroes
    Profiles of U.S. soldiers who've died in Iraq, a look at the war's toll and pictures of mourning.

    Video VideoGo

    CBS White House Correspondent John Roberts reports that many politicians on the Hill are surprised at the lack of action from the Bush administration in response to the Iraq uranium claim.
    Video VideoGo

    White House officials refuse to say the Iraqi uranium report was flat out wrong, and called the media blow-up of the President's speech statement "bull," John Roberts reports.
    Video VideoGo

    The Bush Administration remains on the defensive over the use of questionable intel on Iraq’s nuclear weapons program, while U.S. forces in Iraq are facing more deadly attacks, Teri Okita reports.

    Story StoryGo

    CIA Chief On Senate Hot Seat
    Story StoryGo

    Bush: Niger Doubts Came Late
    Story StoryGo

    Bush: CIA Intelligence 'Darn Good'
    Story StoryGo

    Administration Defends Bush Claim
    Story StoryGo

    Bush Stands By Tenet
    Story StoryGo

    CIA Takes Blame For WMD Flap
    Story StoryGo

    Pat Robertson Slams Bush On Liberia
    Story StoryGo

    CIA Director's Statement
    Story StoryGo

    Blame Game Over False WMD Info
    Story StoryGo

    Bush Knew Iraq Info Was Dubious

    All Broadcasts
    The Early Show 
    CBS Evening News 
    48 Hours 
    60 Minutes 
    60 Minutes II 
    The Sat. Early Show 
    Sunday Morning 
    Face The Nation 
    CBS Morning News 
    Up To The Minute 
    close [x]